Book Club: The Bark of the Bog Owl

As I explained in this post, I am having great fun hosting a young readers book club at my local Christian book store, Cathedral Book and Gift. The second book in our middle grade reader series was The Bark of the Bog Owl by Jonathan Rogers. Bark is a fantastic first book in a very worthy trilogy. We reviewed Bark here and the Wilderking Trilogy here.


Absolutely one of my favorite children’s series of all time (I really mean that), I was particularly excited about this book club. Like any great book, The Bark of the Bog Owl can be read on several levels. On the surface level, it is an exciting story about a boy and how he becomes a hero. On a didactic level, it is a pleasant exposition on friendship. On a literary level, it delights the reader with poetry, elegant prose, unexpected humor, and a nod to the really great books that came before it. On a spiritual level, the comparison to David and Goliath is impossible to miss and this reimagining tickles our moral imagination while giving us the opportunity to consider what young David must have been like behind the scenes of the great biblical drama.

The grand and substantial nature of this story makes it a natural choice for a book club but it also poses an incredible challenge to a book club leader: which direction shall we go? There is more in this one story than we could unpack in several book clubs.

Many moons ago, I fell in love with a series of 31 posts at Mt. Hope Chronicles about being Book Club Detectives. It is a fantastic, and I mean fantastic, resource. I implore you to go check it out. Really, just open that open in a new window, make a cuppa coffee or tea, and have a wonderful read. I’ll wait right here.

Theft is the most sincere form of flattery, right? I hope so. Re-reading Heidi’s posts last month, I realized that that technique would be just the thing that I needed for this book club. In fact, it is just the thing to get me through many of the upcoming book clubs as well. Flexible, thoughtful, concrete, and instructive, the story map and the Book Club Detective approach is an easy way to get the book club discussion off in a good direction. As Heidi mentions, her idea came from a brilliant book called Deconstructing Penguins (the affiliate link for that book is for Heidi’s blog – I will proudly steal her idea but I won’t steal her referral fee – 😉 ) and the story map she is using is based on a story map that Center For Lit uses in their Teaching the Classics guides. I am a Pelican member at Center For Lit and have also loved the way that they map out a story.

And so, armed with my copy of Deconstructing Penguins, inspired by Heidi and Center For Lit, and excited about Aidan, I took a stab at mapping out The Bark of the Bog Owl.

Screen Shot 2017-08-05 at 4.33.08 PM

Breathing easier, because I had a plan for our discussion, I decided to play with one more idea – a Venn Diagram. The comparison between Aidan and David was too good to pass on. I wanted my book club attendees to find more reasons to love David and Aidan more by loving the other as well.

Screen Shot 2017-08-05 at 4.35.13 PM

Ten kids aged between 6 and 14 showed up on our cold and rainy August day. We opened with prayer and then we launched right into a discussion about what an allegory is. Explaining that Pilgrims Progress is an allegory and that The Bark of the Bog Owl is not, we talked about what Bark was since it was so familiar to the David story. Once we settled on “re-imagining,” our juices were flowing and we were ready to treat the story as something more than just a fun adventure.


I realized that the kids might really enjoy applying this story mapping process to other books that they read. In the hopes that they will come back for more book club meetings and continue reading like book detectives, I laminated a blank story map template for them with a teaching map on the back. Screen Shot 2017-08-05 at 4.41.48 PMScreen Shot 2017-08-05 at 4.41.34 PM

For the meeting, I took each bubble and made it large enough for us to write on as the discussion evolved.


I also made snacks. I am never going to be the arts and crafts mom. I am also not the “let’s do a skit” mom. I am not even the “this is a great activity to go with the story” mom. I am the “I have a snack for that” mom. In 1 Samuel, Israel is at war with the Philistines. David’s father sends his son to the battle field with a sack filled with ten kinds of bread and ten kinds of cheese to be shared with his brothers’ part of the army. In Bark, Rogers repeats this beautiful imagery by sending Aidan to the battle with the Prythens with a sack filled with bread and cheese. I couldn’t resist the opportunity to introduce the kids to some traditional Jewish bread recipes.


I was looking for bread recipes that would be authentic and traditionally Jewish such that they might have been included in David’s bag. I was hoping to find something flexible enough that it might also have been in Aidan’s bag as well. Ultimately, inspired by traditional Nut and Date bread recipes, I created this recipe by blending several recipes. Typically, Jewish Nut and Date does not have raisins in it. I thought that by adding raisins we could make it something that Aidan would have liked too. 

Screen Shot 2017-08-04 at 5.00.01 PM

This photo is a bit grainy. You can download a PDF version here.

In a similar quest to find a bread that could double as being in Aidan and David’s bread, I settled on traditional Rosh Hashanah Honey Cake. The honey cake symbolizes the Jewish hope for sweet and victorious things to come. I thought that that was appropriate to this battle scene. Again, using a variety of recipes and blending them until I came up with something I liked, I created this.

Screen Shot 2017-08-05 at 5.10.25 PM.png

Again, I think that the photo is grainy. The PDF version can be found here.

Finally, every time I talk about The Bark of the Bog Owl, I think about how those final chapters remind me of The Princess and the Goblin. I enjoyed telling the kids about that George MacDonald masterpiece that G. K. Chesterton said made all of the difference in his life. Beloved by Chesterton, C.S. Lewis, J.R.R. Tolkien and those who love them, I am hoping to journey with these kids through the goblin tunnels next month.

Book Club Resources:

Quotes in PDF
Blank Story Map
Explained Story Map
Bark Story Map
Blank Bubbles for Club Leader
Venn Diagram
Shepherd Boy Date and Nut Bread
5 Stones Honey Cake



  1. Shanna says:

    Sara you are such a wonderful and sparkling resource! Could you explain how you use The Pelican Society? I really have to hone my subscriptions. I looove Bibliophiles podcasts and Teaching the Classics is on my list, in fact your example has prodded me to bring it to my coop for a book club. It is actually wonderful to have more quality resources to choose from, but still, I must choose?

    I am also working on my own mama curriculum for this year following your many-books-at-a-time model.

    1. Shanna says:

      Haha, coop! Just us hens!

    2. Sara Masarik says:

      Oh Shanna! So very kind of you to say! I have been a Pelican member for, um, seven weeks… 😉 I don’t have much to report yet. That said, I joined so that I could get a few of their Teacher Guides (every six weeks they post a new one for free and the old ones move into their store) and try them. It also gives me a discount in the store. So, I bought a few resources at discount, got “Johnny Tremain” and “Pride and Prejudice” for free ($8 in the store). My son is reading JT right now and I had planned to blog through our JT Teacher guide experience once he has finished it and we can take the guide for a spin.

      I happen to have a natural bias towards the Center for Lit folks. They are Hillsdale grads, as am I. That may sound parochial or tribal, but I think that it reveals how highly I value the Great Books education that we all enjoyed. The way that Hillsdale taught us to read gives me confidence that what they are doing is solid.

      Bravo for your own self education plan. You can always always always change whatever isn’t working. I re-calibrate weekly and monthly. Some seasons I can read more than others. I hope that you find blessings in your efforts!

  2. Shanna says:

    PS I don’t know if I reviewed it or not, but I loved hearing your speaking voice on Pam’s show, it’s just as sparkling as your writing voice.

    1. Sara Masarik says:

      Oh my gosh. ((blush)) Thank you. Thank you. I was so nervous until we started. Then I had so much fun!!

  3. Thanks for these lovely ideas, Sara! Do you have any discussion questions you used with the book? I’ve been eager to read this with my kiddos. The recipes will be a big hit! Thanks!

    1. Sara Masarik says:

      Hello Christina! What I did instead of using questions was to work with the kids to map the story. In this way we talked about what the setting was – what did it remind us of? How is it different from the bible? Did it remind us of other stories? Next we talked about the rising action – which things contributed to the real push of the story? When we talked about the climax we debated where that climax was – with Griedwald or in the mines? Somewhere else? Something else? By using the story map that is included in this book club kit, we were able to really get our heads around the story and contemplate the layers.

      Happy reading!!

Comments are closed.